Awww, those are cute! Finally, some wholesome, classic Internet concern in this forum.

I could take one that won't get picked by others, the most unwanted one of the litter. The one with the personality that's harder to tame, or the one that's least attractive. I think those too deserve a chance for love or redemption.

[OP doesn't seem the type to throw them out so it won't be like with his previous pet, but...]